Fertilisers & substrates 5 min read

Soil, coco or hydro: which substrate suits you?

Soil, coco and hydro compared: buffer, watering, feeding, pH range, effort, costs and pot sizes, with a comparison table and a clear recommendation for getting started.

For getting started, pre-fertilised soil is the safest choice: it buffers mistakes in watering and feeding, needs little measuring equipment and sits in the pH range of 6.0 to 7.0. Coco is airier and can be controlled more precisely, but you water and feed more often, compensate for calcium and magnesium and keep the pH at around 5.5 to 6.5. Hydro with clay pebbles offers the most control but has almost no buffer: you have to check the nutrient solution, pH and EC constantly, and you also need a pump and a tank. In short: soil is the most forgiving, hydro the least, and coco sits in between.

What is the difference between soil, coco and hydro?

The most important difference is the buffer, i.e. how strongly the substrate absorbs fluctuations in water, nutrients and pH. Soil contains organic matter and usually a basic supply of fertiliser. It holds on to nutrients and releases them slowly. Coco fibre brings hardly any nutrients of its own but holds a lot of water while staying airy. According to Canna, clay pebbles are inorganic and pH-neutral; they only hold the roots in place, and the supply comes entirely from the nutrient solution.

FeatureSoilCocoHydro (clay pebbles)
Bufferhighmediumvery low
Wateringwhen the top 2 to 3 cm are drymore often, in smaller amountsautomatically by pump
Feedingpre-fertilised soil: none at first, then according to schedulewith almost every wateringconstantly via the nutrient solution
pH range6.0 to 7.05.5 to 6.55.5 to 6.5
Measuring effortpH of the irrigation water occasionallypH and EC regularlypH and EC constantly
Error tolerancehighmediumlow
Start-up costslow: bag of soil, potslow to medium: substrate, coco nutrients, CalMag, meterhigh: system with pump and tank, measuring equipment
Typical final pot10 to 20 le.g. 11 ldepending on the system, e.g. 11 l

The ranges summarise several sources. For coco, Canna and 420-Hub give a narrower 5.5 to 6.2, Nordleaf 5.5 to 6.5.

How often do I need to water and feed?

Soil: Only water when the top 2 to 3 cm are dry. Overwatering is considered the most common beginner's mistake, because wet soil deprives the roots of air. According to the manufacturer, heavily pre-fertilised soil such as BioBizz All·Mix supplies the plants for a few weeks without additional fertiliser; lightly pre-fertilised soils such as BioBizz Light·Mix or Plagron Lightmix only cover the start, Plagron Lightmix about one week according to the product information. After that you feed according to schedule.

Coco: According to Canna, coco holds around a third more water than comparable peat substrates, but often looks drier than it is. You water more often and in smaller amounts until a little water runs out at the bottom. Because coco stores hardly any nutrients, fertiliser goes into the water with almost every watering. Canna points out that plain water can wash out the buffer that has been built up.

Hydro: A pump delivers the nutrient solution to the roots on a timer. You do not water by hand, but you check the fill level, pH and EC in the tank and replace the solution as specified by the manufacturer. Canna makes a clear distinction here: Aqua nutrients for systems in which the solution runs back into the tank, Hydro nutrients for systems without return flow.

Why does coco need calcium and magnesium?

Coco fibre binds calcium and magnesium and releases potassium in return. Without compensation, the plants lack these nutrients even though they are being fed. That is why there is buffered coco, which has been saturated with them beforehand, and coco nutrients with increased calcium and magnesium content. Many growers also add a CalMag product such as BioBizz CalMag or Hesi CalMag to the water.

What pH do the substrates need?

For soil it is 6.0 to 7.0, for coco and hydro 5.5 to 6.5. Plagron specifies a pH of 6 to 7 for Lightmix. In soil the buffer has a balancing effect; with coco, and even more so with hydro, a wrong pH quickly affects nutrient uptake. How to measure, calibrate and adjust the value correctly is explained in the guide Measuring pH and EC.

Which substrate do we recommend for beginners?

Start with pre-fertilised soil. You get to know watering and feeding without every mistake showing up immediately. This is how to go about it:

  1. Choose the soil: All·Mix if you want to feed as little as possible at first, Light·Mix or Plagron Lightmix if you want to control feeding yourself right from the start.
  2. Prepare the soil: According to BioBizz, moisten All·Mix and let it rest for 36 hours before the plant goes in. For more air in the pot you can mix in Plagron Perlite, 10 to 35 % according to the manufacturer.
  3. Start small: Young plants in 0.5 to 1 litre, later 3 to 5 litres and finally 10 to 20 litres, for example in the square plant pot or in the fabric pot. Repot when roots grow out of the bottom.
  4. Feed to match: Soil goes with a soil fertiliser, for example the BioBizz Starter Kit, Bio·Grow and Bio·Bloom or the Hesi Starter Kit Soil. Dose according to the manufacturer's schedule.
  5. Check the pH of the irrigation water: In soil, doing this occasionally is enough; a drop test or a simple meter will do.

If you switch to coco later, BioBizz Coco·Mix goes well with a coco fertiliser such as Hesi Coco. For hydro there are complete systems such as the Atami Wilma Large 4 with return flow into the tank, which pairs with a fertiliser for recirculating systems such as Canna Aqua Vega. Clay pebbles are not currently listed in the online shop; ask us about them in the shop.

Common mistakes: what often goes wrong when choosing a substrate?

  • Watered too often: In soil in particular, wet roots suffocate. Only water when the top few centimetres are dry.
  • Wrong fertiliser: Soil fertiliser on coco or hydro leads to deficiencies. The fertiliser must match the substrate.
  • Coco without compensation: Unbuffered coco without CalMag binds calcium and magnesium, and the plant shows deficiencies despite being fed.
  • Pre-fertilised soil fed additionally: All·Mix brings enough for the first few weeks. Extra fertiliser too early overloads young plants.
  • Clay pebbles not rinsed: According to Canna, rinse off loose particles before use, otherwise they clog the pump and drippers.
  • Moving to hydro too early: Without a meter and constant monitoring, there is no buffer to absorb mistakes.

In our shop at Lorenzstraße 9 in Hof we have soils from BioBizz and Plagron, coco and the matching fertilisers in stock and help you put everything together. Online you will find everything under Substrates, Fertilisers and Hydroponics.

Featured in this guide

Frequently asked questions

Can I use ordinary potting compost from the DIY store?

You can, but it is often not ideal. Multi-purpose compost is cheap but frequently too rich in nutrients. Special soils such as Light·Mix or Plagron Lightmix are looser and their pre-fertilisation is precisely described.

Can I mix soil and coco?

Yes. Some soils such as Plagron Lightmix already contain perlite for more air. With your own mixes, base watering and feeding on the main component. If in doubt, a ready-made mix is easier to handle.

Can coco be reused?

In principle, yes. Remove root residue, rinse thoroughly and resupply it with nutrients before the next use. Over time coco loses its structure; then fresh substrate or perlite helps.

Do I need different fertilisers for coco than for soil?

Yes. Coco stores hardly any nutrients and binds calcium and magnesium, which is why there are dedicated coco fertilisers, often supplemented with CalMag. Soil fertilisers are matched to the reserves and buffer of the soil.

What is the difference between Aqua and Hydro nutrients from Canna?

Canna Aqua is intended for systems in which the nutrient solution runs back into the tank, for example ebb and flow or drip systems with return flow. Canna Hydro is for systems without return flow, where every feed is mixed fresh. Canna expressly advises against confusing the two.

Sources

All information to the best of our knowledge and based on manufacturer data as of the date shown. It does not replace the manufacturer’s instructions. This guide was created with AI assistance and reviewed by our team.

More from Fertilisers & substrates